Eager to know which Thanksgiving pie steals the show in different states? Google’s “most searched” pies hold the key to uncovering the diverse and delicious pie choices that capture the hearts of Americans!

Before we reveal California’s favorite Thanksgiving pie, let’s have a little history lesson about the evolution of the pie!

The History of the Thanksgiving Pie

Thanksgiving beckons with the promise of a grand feast, and at its heart lies the timeless tradition of pies—a sweet embodiment of gratitude and indulgence woven into the very fabric of our celebrations. The journey of pies takes us back to early civilizations, evolving from simple crusts in Egypt and Greece to culinary masterpieces in the hands of the Romans, who introduced an array of diverse fillings.

Fast forward to medieval Europe, where pies evolved into vessels for both sweet and savory delights. As European settlers brought this cherished tradition to the New World, pies adapted to showcase locally available ingredients. While pumpkin pie has become an iconic symbol of Thanksgiving, the Pilgrims and Native Americans likely relished an array of savory pies during their inaugural feast.

The 19th century marked Thanksgiving’s ascent to a national holiday, firmly entrenching pies as a centerpiece of the celebratory meal. The advent of ready-made crusts and canned fillings democratized pie-making, contributing to the widespread tradition of baking pies for Thanksgiving. As we gather around the table, each slice becomes more than a culinary creation; it is a continuation of a centuries-old tradition—a delicious thread seamlessly woven into the rich tapestry of our celebrations.

And the Winner Is …

Drumroll, please! The most-searched Thanksgiving pie in California is… Pumpkin! While it may sound like a classic choice, there’s always room for a twist. If you’re up for a culinary adventure, check out this fantastic pumpkin pie recipe.

And, of course, if you’re in the mood for sharing, feel free to drop a delicious slice off at my house! Wishing all my clients and friends a Happy Thanksgiving!

217 total views, 1 views today